Application of various cooling schemes for outboard heat exchangers
EDN: IHWAOE
Abstract
The purpose of the article is to consider the problems of dual-circuit and single-circuit cooling systems to improve reliability.
The article discusses the causes of accidents on ships related to flooding of engine rooms due to corrosion damage to pipes and elements in two-circuit cooling systems. It is pointed out that, despite the regulatory requirements of the Register aimed at improving the reliability of such systems, the problems of corrosion wear of pipelines remain relevant and affect the operation of ships. To completely eliminate the dangers of flooding, it is proposed to use single-circuit systems with outboard coolers more widely. The main limitation for the wider use of outboard heat exchangers is noted: a low heat transfer coefficient due to the natural circulation of outboard water in a warm box and restrictions in the Register Rules for the use of keel coolers for ice-class vessels. To expand the use of outboard coolers on ships, it is proposed to introduce a new type of cooler in the Register Rules, the definition of which is proposed to be added to the Register Rules. This will make it possible to apply less stringent requirements to such coolers compared to keel coolers, which will expand their use on ice navigation vessels. To intensify heat exchange in outboard coolers, measures are proposed to optimize the design of thermal and kingston boxes by organizing natural circulation in them or creating forced circulation of outboard water through the cooler using a water jet ejector using a fire protection system.
About the Authors
V. K. ShurpyakRussian Federation
PhD
191181; Millionnaya ul., 7A; St. Petersburg
А. V. Rogozin
Russian Federation
Assistant Professor
190121; Lotsmanskaya ul., 3; St. Petersburg
А. А. Mikheeva
Russian Federation
Lead R&D Specialist, PhD student
191181; Millionnaya ul., 7A; St. Petersburg; Moscow
References
1. Gannesen V.V., Solov'eva E.E. The accident rate of sea vessels and the methodology for searching for the accident causes. Scientific Journal of the Far Eastern State Technical Fisheries University. 2022. Vol. 61. No 3. P. 70 — 76. (In Russ.)
2. Motrich V.N. 2022 god: avariinost' morskogo flota [2022: Maritime fleet accident rate]. Morskie vesti Rossii [Maritime News of Russia]. 27. 10. 2023. URL: https://morvesti.ru/themes/1693/105728/ (accessed 04. 02. 2025).
3. Motrich V.N. Avariinost' morskogo flota [Maritime fleet accident rate]. Morskie vesti Rossii [Maritime News of Russia]. 24. 09. 2024. URL: https://morvesti.ru/themes/1693/111604/ (accessed 04. 02. 2025).
4. Shurpyak V.K., Sergeev A.A. Analysis of the average accident rate of RS classed ships. Transactions of Russian Maritime Register of Shipping. 2005. Issue 28. P. 32 — 46.
5. Makarov V.G., Shurpyak V.K. Novye trebovaniia Registra k zashchite ot korrozii sudovykh truboprovodov [New Register requirements for corrosion protection of ship pipelines]. Transactions of Russian Maritime Register of Shipping. 1999. Issue 22. P. 194 — 206.
6. RD5.5104-79 Metodika rascheta bezotkaznosti i dolgovechnosti elementov i dopustimye skorosti potoka morskoi vody [Methodology for calculation of reliability and durability of elements and allowable seawater flow rates].
7. Golub E.S., Shurpyak V.K. Otsenka tekhnicheskogo sostoianiia truboprovodov zabortnoi vody soglasno novym dokumentam Registra [Assessment of the technical condition of seawater pipelines according to the new Register documents]. Transactions of Russian Maritime Register of Shipping. 2000. Issue 23. P. 216 — 227.
8. Harlamova A.E., Pokusaev M.N., Trifonov A.V. Analysis of ship accidents caused by unreliable operation of cooling systems of ship power plants. Vestnik of Astrakhan State Technical University. Series: Marine engineering and technologies. 2023. Vol. 2. P. 30 — 40. DOI: 10.24143/2073-1574-2023-2-30-40. EDN: QCWWRO. (In Russ.)
9. Shurpyak V.K., Serov A.A. Evaluation of influence of main ship systems on the ship energy efficiency indices. Research Bulletin by Russian Maritime Register of Shipping. 2017. No. 48/49. P. 95 — 103. (In Russ.)
10. Fedorovskii K.Yu., Fedorovskaia N.K. Zamknutye sistemy okhlazhdeniia sudovykh energeticheskikh ustanovok [Closed-circuit cooling systems for ship power plants]. Moscow: Vuzovskii uchebnik; INFRA-M, 2017. 164 p. (In Russ.)
11. Gorelik B.A., Shurpyak V.K. Hazards identification and risk assessment of ship piping. Transactions of Russian Maritime Register of Shipping. 2009. Issue 32. P. 156 — 170. (In Russ.)
12. Orlova E.G., Shurpyak V.K. Efficiency assessment of ship cooling systems equipped with box coolers. Transactions of Russian Maritime Register of Shipping. 2008. Issue 31. P. 245 — 259. (In Russ.)
13. Tkach S., Sviridenko I., Tkach O. Experimental researches of heat emission of outboard cooler in the conditions of free-convective and gas-liquid flow of sea water. Visnik SevNTU. 2013. Vol. 137. P. 351 — 354. EDN: RBIDIH. (In Russ.)
Review
For citations:
Shurpyak V.K., Rogozin А.V., Mikheeva А.А. Application of various cooling schemes for outboard heat exchangers. Research Bulletin by Russian Maritime Register of Shipping. 2025;(78):155-171. (In Russ.) EDN: IHWAOE